Home > Eating, New York City, North America > NYC Sushi: Ichimura at Brushstroke (Feb. 2013)

NYC Sushi: Ichimura at Brushstroke (Feb. 2013)

Author: Victor
Restaurant: Ichimura at Brushstroke
Chef: Eiji Ichimura
Website: http://www.davidbouley.com/brushstroke-main/brushstroke-menus/brushstroke-sushi

Date: February 11, 2013


I’ve been wanting to try this sushi bar–only restaurant for a while now. It’s in a more private dining area than the main dining area of Brushstroke, and there’s been a lot of hype around this restaurant. Reservations are pretty hard to get for this place right now, and there are only 16 covers a night (two rounds of eight).

2A Inside

There was a pretty large selection of fish, and apparently the vast majority of the fish gets shipped from Japan every few days. Everything was really fresh and high quality. Chef Ichimura had the usual choices (tai, saba, otoro, kohada, uni, and so on), but it was nice being able to try kuromutsu (black bluefish), higetara (a type of cod) , shirasu (baby anchovy), and shiraou (icefish).

The rice was soft and fluffy, though I like the sushi rice more at a few other places in NYC (like Yasuda). On the negative side, it started off too warm at first before finally getting to a good temperature (just sliiiiiiiightly above room temperature).

Anyway, you start off with an appetizer or two (chawanmushi and then some fish/vegetable bite-sized tastings) before trying sashimi, sushi, or a mix of the two. I went sushi-only because I was in a sushi mood. (Then again, I’m usually in a sushi mood…)

Positive dishes/pieces:
-The anago, akamutsu, kuromutsu, tai, and uni were really good.
-The ōtoro and chūtoro were AMAZING. Winter is a great time for toro haha ^_^.

Negative dishes/pieces:
-The one disappointing part was the tamago, which didn’t taste special at all.

I had a really good time here, and I thought the meal was really well-priced for what you get. The value to quality and quantity ratio is REALLY good here for sushi! Chef Ichimura is also REALLY nice. That might have helped haha.


Appetizer 1:
Chawanmushi with black truffles, crab meat, chives, and fresh ginger.

4 A1 Chawanmushi

There wasn’t too much egg in this chawanmushi, but the egg portions definitely worked well with the crab portions. The black truffles, chives, and fresh ginger added some nuance and complexity to the dish. At the same time, while this was good, I’ve had better chawanmushi at quite a few places.

Appetizer 2:
(Right to left)
1. Uni (sea urchin).
2. Ankimo (monkfish liver) with ponzu sauce.
3. Bamboo shoot with.. something.
4. Himejako (giant clam) with sansho pepper from Kyoto.
5. Marinated tuna with shiso and… something.
6. Herring roe with shiso.
7. Toro with miso and ginger.

5 A2 Appetizers

-The uni was very sweet and fragrant (as I’d expect).
-The ankimo was good and creamy, but I still liked the ankimo I had at Sushi Yoshitake in HK and Tenku Ryugin in HK more.
-The bamboo shoot was surprisingly enjoyable and provided a nice transition from the creamy uni and ankimo to the giant clam
-The himejako with sansho peppers was delicious, but I think I would’ve liked the clam with or without the peppers–they felt a little unnecessary.
-I didn’t really enjoy the herring roe. Maybe it’s an acquired taste.
-The toro melted in my mouth and was amazing (as expected, though–it wasn’t anything new).

6 Preparing Nigiri

Chef Ichimura’s preparing sushi here.


1. Hirami (fluke).

7 S1

The rice is fluffy but REALLY warm. The hirami was solid.

2. Higetara (a type of cod).

8 S2

3. Kinmedai (golden eye snapper).

9 S3

Hmm, the rice is better. Temperature is right, and still fluffy! The kinmedai was good.

4. Shirasu (whitebait or baby anchovy) from Kyushu.

10 S4

It was a little fishy but was still really pleasant to eat and easy to enjoy. I’ve never had a sushi piece with any kind of anchovies.

(Apparently, baby anchovies are called shirasu, while adult anchovies are called shirauo.)

5. Tai (red snapper) with shiso and salt.

11 S5

This was gooooood–basically what happiness tastes like.

6. Shiraou (icefish or noodlefish).

12 S6

7. Shima aji (striped jack) belly.

13 S7

This didn’t melt in my mouth like I was hoping it would. However, I’ve never had shima aji belly, so maybe it doesn’t do that. It tasted really fresh.

8. Akamutsu (red bluefish).

14 S8

9. Kuromutsu (black bluefish).

15 S9

I had this almost immediately after the akamutsu, and they tasted really similar with some slight differences. Unfortunately, I was just enjoying the pieces here and didn’t really pay attention to those differences haha :(.

10. Saba (mackerel) from Nagasaki with salt and vinegar.

16 S10

I’m not sure the salt and vinegar were necessary. Then again, the saba taste was very intense, and the salt and vinegar definitely helped temper that a bit.

11. Sayuri (needlefish).

17 S11

12. Kohada (gizzard shad) with salt and vinegar.

18 S12

Goooood. It was a little fishy as usual, but i’ve never had kohada that wasn’t at least a little fishy.

13. Aji (horse mackerel).

19 S13

The aji didn’t really melt in mouth, but it was still really flavorful.

14. Uni (sea urchin).

20 S14

Sweeeeet and creamy!

15. Bluefin Ōtoro (fatty tuna).

21 S15

SO GOOD. Melted in my mouth, where an explosion of intense flavor occurred. Cue the usual statements of “This is what Heaven tastes like”, so on, and so on.

At this point in the meal, I’m thinking to myself, “Was that the climax of the meal? Is it all downhill from here?”

16. Hotate (scallop).

22 S16

Objectively, it was good, though a little hard–I prefer scallops softer. Still, it pales in comparison to the toro. It’s like

17. Aged chūtoro (medium-fatty tuna).

23 S17

HERE WE GO. Back to Heaven! This was amazing. I’m starting to like akami (lean tuna) more and more, even preferring it to toro at times. This still had the fattiness and creaminess of the toro, but it also had a little of the meatiness of tuna that I so enjoy.

At this point, he’s asking if there are any other pieces I want to eat. MUST. KEEP. GOING. (He suggests giant clam and anago, which I gladly accept. I ask if he has any akami, and he’s not sure–he has to check.)

18. Himejako (giant clam).

24 S18

Really similar to other really good himejako that I’ve had.

19. Anago (saltwater eel).

25 S19

It didn’t have any of the sweet sauce, so I tasted a lot more of the actual eel–and it was amazing. It melted in my mouth and was sweet but not too sweet. Hmm… I might actually prefer anago without the sauce…

20. Hand roll with shiso and plum sauce.

26 S20

Chef Ichimura suggested that I finish the seafood with this because it would help my digestion. The seaweed was really good, and the plum sauce and shiso worked well together.

21. Tamago.

27B S21

Unfortunately, the tamago didn’t really taste special at all.

Seasonal fruit and sake kantern.
Orange, grapefruit, red and green grapes, apple, and kumquat. Served with sake gelée.

28 D1

This dessert was very refreshing and sweet, but at the same time it felt really light. This feels like it would be an amazing summertime dessert

  1. November 9, 2019 at 6:34 am

    This is the kind of sleeper hit that critics dream about. Almost nobody was talking about the little sushi bar inside Brushstroke where Eiji Ichimura was quietly refining the techniques

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: